This is my entry in the Siskel and Ebert Blogathon hosted by 18 Cinema Lane
The Gene Siskel and Roger Ebert phenomenon was at the very least a compelling tête-à-tête that appeared weekly on TV. As early as the 1970's in various formats, the two would come on and discuss the current batch of releases in the theater, famously giving either a "thumbs up" or "thumbs down" rating for each movie. Sometimes both would agree on the rating, but then at other times they would disagree.
In particular, as to the disagreement theme, was their view of The Silence of the Lambs. While Siskel berated the movie for lack of compelling characters and the subject matter being a little too sensitive, Ebert actually liked the movie.
I wholeheartedly agree with Ebert's take. Yes the movie does dip a little at the end, what with the "who's behind the next door" typical horror film trope, I feel, however, that both Jodie Foster and Anthony Hopkins deserved their gold statuettes from the Oscars. Hopkins in particular is extremely memorable. You'll probably never hear the word "liver" in the same way after viewing Hopkins tell of his encounter with a census taker. (and BTW, just in case you didn't know, that "thhpthhpthhp" he utters at the end was improvised. It wasn't in the script. And yet his little slurping noise is probable the one most recognizable part of the entire film..)
Both Gene Siskel and Roger Ebert have gone on to do their reviews from "the other side" now. Siskel passed away in 1999 and Ebert left us in 2013.
Silence of the Lambs (1991):
A serial killer is on the loose. Known by the FBI as "Buffalo Bill", he has the habit of kidnapping young girls and cutting them up, removing certain body parts, primarily skin, before disposing of the bodies.
Clarice Starling (Jodie Foster), a young recruit, is given the task of interviewing Hannibal Lecter (Anthony Hopkins), a former psychiatrist who has been imprisoned because of his taste for human flesh and his propensity for killing his prey to quench his tastes.
The task is given to her by her superior and mentor Jack Crawford (Scott Glenn). John Kenneth Muir, in his book Horror Films FAQ, suggests that Crawford is in essence a surrogate father to Clarice, since she lost her father at an early age. He also suggests that on some level that Lecter is also somewhat of a surrogate father (sick as that may seem).
Clarice interviews Lecter, but Lecter gains the upper hand immediately, by demanding a tit for tat. He will only talk about "Buffalo Bill" if Clarice reveals some intimate details of her own life. The most intriguing part of this movie is that tête-à-tête, as Clarice delves into her own past and psyche in order to appease Lecter and get him to open up about his insight into the current case.
Lecter also manages to convince Clarice that a "reward" is appropriate for his insight; that is he will tell her things to help her if she can manage to get him a better arrangement within the prison. Of course Clarice doesn't have that kind of pull, but her boss does. But the deal is hampered by Lecter's nemesis within the prison, the doctor/warden. Dr. Chilton (Anthony Heald) is reluctant to give any concessions to his prisoner. Chilton is a smarmy self-satisfied jackass, and despite the presence of Lecter and "Buffalo Bill" is probably the least appealing character in the movie. (it's almost gratifying when his imminent end is hinted at in the ending of the film).
Through Lecter's help and some luck, eventually Clarice is able to track down "Buffalo Bill", although her luck may just run out, as the film descends into the "who's behind the next door" sequence hinted at above.
One must approach Silence of the Lambs with a bit of an open mind. The fact is that Lecter is alternately disturbing and, at some times, even appealing as a villain. One cannot watch this movie and expect that all will be right in the end, even if one is an optimistic idealist. If you like your movies to be on the dark side, however, it can be a good experience. But don't fool yourself into believing that it will be uplifting.
Well folks, time to head home. Drive safely.
Really good review! I haven't seen this movie in a while, but I do agree with your and Ebert's opinion. This film is not for everyone, but it does a pretty good job at not shying away from subjects that some movies would try to sugarcoat, such as loss, darkness, and what drives people to do the things they do. Thanks for participating in the blogathon! I will add your name and article to the participant list right away.ReplyDelete
I have a dark side to my own psyche (although I'm not a psychopath). I guess thats why I can watch these movies more easily. Thanks for reading.Delete
I forgot to mention in my first comment that the video featuring Anthony Hopkins isn't working properly. I just wanted to tell you that.ReplyDelete
Oh, itworked. You just had to click twice because I inadvertently used a youtube vide made by someone apparently with an overinflated sense of self-importance. He/she had disabled using links. But I fixed it now. A bit longer video but it still has the iconic scene.Delete
I've always stayed away from this film because my sister saw it at a pizza/movie party friend's house and said – and I quote – "I could feel the pizza coming back up." However, I liked your fab review (as always), and appreciated your frankness re: the absence of a feel-good vibe.ReplyDelete
MOST of the movies I review shouldn't have a "feel-good vibe"... :-) I do review some pretty outre stuff. Thanks for reading.Delete
"Feel Good Vibe" is pretty much the last thing I think of when I think about this movie...kind of like the terms "Miami Dolphins" and professional football."ReplyDelete
Happy ending movies are like candy. Too much of them can make me sick to my stomach... :-) Thanks for reading.Delete
Super review of one of my very favorite films. What a strong cast, and a story that hooks you in right from the beginning. I want to write about this one too someday!ReplyDelete
The only thing stopping you from writing, Chris, is you. :-) Look at me. Full time job and another almost full time job spoiling my cat and I still find ways to make time to write... Thanks for reading.Delete