Sunday, November 22, 2026

Semiquincentennial Movie Project #47: The Outsiders


 

The Semiquincentennial  Movie Project is an ongoing celebration of the 250th anniversary of the founding of the United States. During the course of this project your humble blogger is choosing a movie a week to represent each of the 50 states in the Union, as well as a movie scheduled for 4th of July weekend that will represent the nation's capitol, Washington D.C. The order of the weekly entries will coincide with the order of each state's entry into the fold (although, not necessarily coinciding with the date of their entry into said fold).

 


Week #47: Oklahoma -

 



 
 
The state of Oklahoma was established on November 16, 1907. 
   

Details about Oklahoma:

State bird: scissored-tailed flycatcher

State flower: mistletoe

State tree: redbud

Additional historical trivia:

Cimarron County, in the Panhandle region of the state, has borders with 4 other states; Texas, Kansas, Colorado and New Mexico. It's the only county in the entire country to have that distinction.

The shopping cart was invented in Oklahoma in 1937. Surprisingly, there was some resistance to this new-fangled gadget when it first appeared.

A relic of the past nowadays in many places, but the first parking meter was introduced in Oklahoma.

Girl Scout cookies got their start in Muskogee, when a local troop started making them to sell in a local school cafeteria.

There is an American Banjo Museum in Oklahoma City (I mention this one because the banjo is my favorite musical instrument). 

Famous people born in Oklahoma: S, E. Hinton (who wrote the novel on which today's film entry was based), Will Rogers, Sam Walton (founder of Wal-Mart), Ron Howard, Brad Pitt, Chuck Norris, Garth Brooks, Toby Keith, Darrell Royal (legendary University of Texas coach), Mickey Mantle and Jim Thorpe.

 

 

You know, the "could-have-been" list of actors that were almost cast for this film is almost as impressive cast the actual stars. Among those who auditioned for parts were Scott Baio, Robert Downey, Jr., Anthony Michael Hall, Timothy Hutton, Sean Penn, Dennis Quaid and Mickey Rourke. 
 
The actual cast is somewhat of a dream cast in itself. Most of the stars were still on the verge of fame. Almost all of them were only making the first, second or third movie of their respective careers. 

C. Thomas Howell had only appeared as a minor character in E. T. the Extraterrestrial. Ralph Macchio had only one other theatrical role in Up the Academy. Patrick Swayze had only appeared in Skatetown, U.S.A. Emilio Estevez had previously only appeared in Tex. It was the first film for Rob Lowe. Tom Cruise had appeared in only 3 films, including Taps (Risky Business came out after this one...) Matt Dillon had probably the biggest resume with 6 roles prior to this film, beginning with Over the Edge. (Note: I am only including theatrical release status films. There were a smattering of roles in made-for-TV movies among them, but still small enough to consider them on the threshold as opposed to being stars...)

One other interesting casting is the fact that the author of the book, S. E. Hinton, briefly appears as a nurse in the hospital. It reminds me of a similar situation when James Dickey, the author of the novel, was cast as a sheriff at the end of the movie Deliverance. It doesn't happen near as often as it could happen, but when the author is given a cameo role in the film version it's always a neat touch to the connection.  

The film credits, just after the cast listing, say this film is dedicated "to the people who first suggested that it be made... Librarian Jo Ellen Misakian and the students of the Lone Star School in Fresno, California. The story behind that is that the students wrote a letter to Coppola, whom they had chosen as the best director to be able to bring it to the screen. (The letter he got included about 15 pages of the kid's signatures, all in different colors, according to wikipedia). After reading the novel Coppola decided to follow through with the request.

The version I watched was not the original theatrical release. Some years after the film was made Coppola's granddaughter echoed thoughts from contemporary fans of the original novel who had criticized Coppola for leaving out major scenes from the book. It turned out that he had a much bigger film but had pared it down for it's release. But much of it still existed. So in 2005 Coppola released a director's cut, titled The Outsiders: The Complete Novel, which bulked up the film from it's original hour and a half length to almost two hours.  

Having never read the original source material, or, in fact the original theatrical release, I can't make any judgement on that decision. (BTW, when I was a junior in high school we were given a reading assignment. Each of us had to pick one of about a half dozen novels that our teacher had chosen and write a report on it. The Outsiders was one of the choices, but I opted for Dragonflight by Anne McCaffrey, since I was and still am a huge science fiction and fantasy fan.) 

 

 

 

The Outsiders (1983): 

The film is a "coming of age" drama, circa the mid 60's in Oklahoma. It centers on the familial interaction between friends and brothers who are part of a gang called "Greasers". The Greasers are essentially the poor whites from one side of the town and their sworn enemies are a group from the more affluent part of town, called the "Socs" (socials).

The rivalry heats up on various occasions. Even though the Socs are the rich kids, these aren't your typical rich kids. They are just as violent or sometimes even more violent than their adversaries. Any time one or more of one gang intrudes into the other gang's domain, there is sure to be some serious battle going on. It's essentially a drama of class warfare on steroids.

The central character is probably Ponyboy Curtis (C. Thomas Howell). 

Ponyboy

Ponyboy lives with his brothers, Sodapop Curtis (Rob Lowe) and Darrell Curtis (Patrick Swayze), who is also known as "Darry".

 

Sodapop
Darry


 

(Whether the names "Ponyboy" and "Sodapop" are their actual names is not entirely clear. Once again, I never read the book. Maybe it's established there, maybe not...  There is, however, one line in the film that implies that the boys' father had a weird sense of humor and maybe actually gave them those names.)

At some point prior to the start of the film's action the parents of the had died, and Darrell, being the oldest has stepped up to be the responsible adult (if that can be said about him). I guess in the 60's it was not considered strange that a young man of Darrell's age would be allowed to raise his siblings, although there is a threat constantly hanging over the family that the younger boys could be taken by the state and put into foster homes.

Gradually over the course of the film things play out that the two gangs are going to be disruptive. Early on in the film a girl from the Socs side, Cherry (Diane Lane) hooks up with one of the Greasers and this doesn't set too well with the Socs' leaders.  

 

Cherry

The two occasionally have scuffles, but things really come to a head when Ponyboy and his friend, Johnny (Ralph Macchio) get caught alone. The Socs try to drown Ponyboy in a fountain and Johnny, trying to save his friend, ends up killing the leader, Bob (Leif Garrett).

 

Johnny
Bob


The two go on the run and hide out in a church in the mountains, helped by another friend, Dallas (Matt Dillon). 

Dallas

Eventually, after a few days in hiding, Dallas comes to get them and informs the two that Cherry has agreed to testify on their behalf, claiming that Johnny's killing of Bob was an act of self-defense. But on the way back to town they find the church where they were hiding out on fire, with children still inside. Johnny and Ponyboy rush in to help, but in the process Johnny is seriously injured.

Fire

 

At this point I will leave you to watch the rest of the film for yourself. I will tell you that at no point is this supposed to be a feel good movie. There are some serious dramatic sequences going on, and not all of the main cast are going to survive to the final credits. What happens is wholly within the context of the story, however. These are some people who are struggling to survive in a somewhat hostile atmosphere (admittedly not as hostile as some later movies dealing with local gangs, but for the time this movie came off as pretty stark.

Interestingly, the Young Artists Awards committee nominated the film for "Best Family Feature". Not sure what the standards were there... The previous winners for that category had been the like of E.T. the Extraterrestrial, Raiders of the Lost Ark and Touched by Love. The other films in competition that year were Return of the Jedi (the winner), Cross Creek and WarGames. All of those I would take any kids to see. Knowing what this film entailed, I'm not sure I would say the same, even though the original novel is almost required reading for young people. Howell beat out several contenders for Best Actor in the same Awards ceremony, but that category wasn't really hampered by a "family" designation.

As far as financially, the film did manage a profit. With a budget of $10 million, it pulled in just over $25 million in ticket sales. Not an overwhelming boffo success, but a respectable one.  

The film is highly regarded on many ratings formats. Rotten Tomatoes gives the film a 71% rating. Roger Ebert only gave the film 2 and a half stars out of 4, but his main issue appears to be with the director's vision rather than the actual content. He said that Coppola "seems so hung up with his notions of a particular movie “look,” with his perfectionistic lighting and framing and composition, that the characters wind up like pictures, framed and hanging on the screen."

Personally, I didn't have a huge problem with any such things as "lighting and framing". My main issue was more with the story itself. And that blame more rightly should be on the author's shoulders. True, it is supposedly based on her own real experiences, but the characters don't exactly appeal to me. Maybe it's because I was raised in such a small town (population 800-900 when I graduated in 1980). The grittiness that this film entails was no where to be seen in my experience. There was division in the school between the jocks and the brainier ones, but no one actually took to the streets with violence.

I have to say it's not altogether a bad film, however. And you can easily see the potential of many of the actors for what was soon to come.  Swayze in particular stood out, as did Macchio and Dillon. Haven't really seen enough of Howell's output, but what I have seen pretty much plays out that potential, too. (Most of my readers probably know what I think of Cruise, so I won't rehash it here...)

So, in ending, I say give it a shot. 

Until next time, drive safely, folks.

Quiggy

 


 


Sunday, November 15, 2026

Semiquincentennial Movie Project # 46: Carnival of Souls


 

The Semiquincentennial  Movie Project is an ongoing celebration of the 250th anniversary of the founding of the United States. During the course of this project your humble blogger is choosing a movie a week to represent each of the 50 states in the Union, as well as a movie scheduled for 4th of July weekend that will represent the nation's capitol, Washington D.C. The order of the weekly entries will coincide with the order of each state's entry into the fold (although, not necessarily coinciding with the date of their entry into said fold).

 



Week #46: Utah -

 


 
 
 
The state of Utah was established on January 4, 1896 

Details about Utah:

State bird: California gull    

State flower: sego lily

State tree: blue spruce 

Additional historical trivia:

It's one of four states that intersect with each other. The other three are Colorado, New Mexico and Arizona (which this same trivia piece will appear...) 


 

The flag pictured above is one of those rarities of a recent change (much like Mississippi). It was changed in 2011. For most of it's existence the Utah state flag was different.

 


The John Wayne film The Conqueror was filmed near St. George. The film is infamously blamed for the high cancer rate of those involved in the filming, because of the nuclear testing that occurred nearby (not during filming, but it still gets blamed).

Utah is unique in the fact that it is the only state with an official State Cooking Pot. It's the Dutch oven.

Salt Lake City is the site where the first Kentucky Fried Chicken franchise opened. (Not the invention of it; that actually DID occur in Kentucky. Just the first place that was officially called KFC...) 

Famous people born in Utah: Hal Ashby (director of Being There, The Last Detail and Harold and Maude),  James Woods, Roseanne Barr, Donny and Marie Osmond, J. W. Marriott, Steve Young and Philo T. Farnsworth (supposed inventor of the television). Not surprisingly, so were many well known names in the Mormon Church.

 

 


 

Carnival of Souls (1962): 

Carnival of Souls is considered a landmark film. But it wasn't always that way. On it's release it went mostly unnoticed. The director, Herk Harvey, never made another theatrically released film. His primary output was those educational films that many people of a certain age remember seeing in high school health and social studies classes. Titles like Street Safety is Your Problem, Health: Your Posture, None for the Road and What About Juvenile Delinquency?, the kind of educational scare tactics films many of us growing up in the 60's and 70's would find familiar.

Carnival of Souls, more or less, was just an attempt by Harvey to prove to himself he could pull off a feature length film. The movie was made on such a micro budget that I think most of it just came from cadging local business into chipping in to pay the bills. Since it was filmed by a group based in Lawrence, Ks, it has a connection with some friends I have made in recent years, although it is supposedly set in Salt Lake City, Utah.  

Besides the director, virtually nobody in this film ever transitioned to a career in the film industry.  The star, Candace Hilligoss, had only 8 films to her IMDb credit. The woman that appears as Mrs. Thomas, Frances Feist, must have been friends with Harvey, because every other credit she had was as a character in one of his educational shorts. The sleazy neighbor, John Linden, was played by Sidney Berger, and his only credits were this and the remake of the film from 1989 (They remade this film...?)

The other major character in the film, the ghoul credited as only "The Man" was played by Harvey himself. Harvey made the film with a total of only 6 people behind the camera, which is why it only cost $30,000 to make. But that low budget cost is not necessarily an indication of the quality of the film. Sure it comes off as a cheap horror film, but like another film from the same era, Night of the Living Dead, the film is immensely intriguing to watch. Not because the actors are really any damn good. Hilligoss is the best part in that respect. The rest of the cast just seems to be going through the motions.

What really impresses and holds my attention with this film is the music. The music, done by a guy named Gene Moore, really captures the haunting feel of the film. The story is somewhat reminiscent of a Twilight Zone episode, especially "The Hitch-hiker", which also involves a woman being haunted by a mysterious stranger who keeps showing up at odd moments.

The film starts off as three girls end up in a drag race with some boys, and their car ends up going off a rather decrepit bridge into a river. There is some sort of mumbo jumbo about the current probably taking that car far downstream, (although that river doesn't really appear to be moving fast enough to sail a paper boat...) 


Mary (Hilligoss) climbs out of the river, apparently the only survivor. She becomes increasingly isolated in her demeanor and decides to move on, away from town. 


She takes a job in Salt Lake City where she is going to be a hired church organist. (Don't most churches just get someone in the church to do that?) There are several little details like that that don't make much sense, but you have to go with it because the film refuses to explain any of these things.

 


Mary moves into a boarding house run by Mrs. Thomas (Feist), who has only one other tenant, the somewhat sleazy John (Berger). 


Early on John develops a rather intrusive obsession with Mary. Personally I would rather spend a few minutes with "The Man" than an hour with John. John wants Mary for basically one thing, and this being the early 60's, he doesn't come right out and say it, but it isn't really all that much of a secret.

 


Mary has problems. Psychologically she is somewhat of a recluse, whether this is a result of a guilt complex for being the only survivor of that car wreck or it's something else entirely is not really dwelt on. It might be because she doesn't have a clear grasp on reality. There is that nagging recurrent appearance of "The Man", whom no one but she sees. 


She also, at times finds herself drifting into some kind of fantasy, wherein she is physically in the world, but hears no sound and can not get anyone to respond to her and acknowledge her presence.

Some sites refer to this as a zombie movie, although my Frightfest Guide to Ghost Movies includes it as one of it's selection for "ghost movies". I leave it up to you, but my opinion is these things act much more like ghosts than zombies, even though on occasion they shuffle along like characters reminiscent of Night of the Living Dead, and in fact George A. Romero cites this movie as one of his inspirations for making that classic.

 


Of course, by the end of the film most everyone in the audience should be aware that she actually did NOT survive that car crash. What is not exactly clear is whether she is having these experiences in her own mind as she is dying or if, like in the classic Twilight Zone episode, she is dead but just hasn't come to grips with that fact and is wandering through a kind of afterlife.

This is one film that will stick with you long after you've finished watching it. It's an arthouse film without an arthouse aesthetic. You shouldn't come into it expecting something like Häxan or Eraserhead, but you shouldn't dismiss it as cheap low budget tripe either. 

Even though Hilligoss barely holds her own on some occasions, you can't help but feel some sympathy for what she is going through. In that sense she is like quite a number of characters in the aforementioned TZ episodes. For instance; most of the actors in the "Five Characters in Search of an Exit" episode of that series are really not all that good, but the situation and trials that the characters have to go through during it stir up emotions that otherwise might not have triggered any emotion.

I have not yet seen that remake from 1989. It apparently is no where close to being as good as the original, however. This version garners a 87% Fresh rating on Rotten Tomatoes, and although it didn't get much attention on it's initial release, in retrospect it has become highly regarded. Two lists of the "greatest horror movies of all time" quoted in the wikipedia article on the film put it in the top 50. The Criterion company, which usually doesn't waste time with junk, has put out a DVD version, complete with an audio commentary by the writers and the director, and a documentary on the Saltair Resort, an abandoned resort where many of the scenes were filmed.

Until next time folks, drive safely. And it should go without saying... don't get suckered into a drag race, especially if part of the race involves going over a rickety bridge that should have been condemned when Eisenhower was still President...

 Quiggy

 


 

 

Friday, November 13, 2026

New Humbug?


 


 

Note: This makes only the fourth time in the history of this blog that I have decided to address a film that is in current release. As such, there is a limited amount of information I can include. For instance, since I haven't got a credit list I can refer to, often I will have to address parts of the film without any data to enhance it. Apologies. I thought it well worth a departure. 

 



Ebenezer (2026):  

The film, as it should be obvious, is yet another adaptation of the classic Dickens story A Christmas Carol. As such, it remains at heart the traditional tale of redemption for which the original story is famous. It does take a few liberties in this retelling, none of which really detract from the story.

The most obvious alteration involves a 10 minute opening, which takes place 7 years before the standard story started. If you know the story by heart, you can probably see where this is going. 

Yes, at the beginning of the film Jacob Marley (Ian McKellen)  is still alive and well. And we get to see how much of an influence the partner may have had on Scrooge (Johnny Depp). But shortly into the film Marley is taken out of the picture. (The original Dickens story did note that Marley had died on Christmas Eve seven years before the events of the story took place...)

 

Ebenezer Scrooge
Jacob Marley
 


 

The movie transitions to what we normally expect from a rendition of the story. Seven years later, now the present in the context of the film, Scrooge interacts with the standard characters that he is bound to meet prior to his night of revelation, including the rather rude dismissal of a couple of charity seekers and his curt refusal to join his nephew Fred (Sam Claflin) in the traditional Christmas dinner that Fred has always invited him to participate. 

 

Fred

There is also the rather shabby treatment of his employee, Bob Cratchit (Ruprert Grint).   

 

Bob Cratchit with Scrooge

 

The film doesn't exactly depart from the story, as such, with the ghosts. We still get Marley returning from the dead to inform Scrooge of his impending trip into what is going to be his reformation. However, in departure from most of the more classic versions of the film, Marley, as well as most of the ghosts, are visually creepy. 

 

Jacob's ghost

 

On that note, I have to tell those of you who read this blog with children of an impressionable age, this is definitely NOT a family movie (in case that pic above doesn't reveal it already...). Some of the ghosts could conceivably be a bit much. But then, it is rated PG-13... nothing overtly sexual, but the graphics are a bit stark.

For instance, The Ghost of Christmas Present (Andrea Riseborough) even gave me some chills. And I have seen some pretty graphic stuff over the years. One of the things that impressed me most about Riseborough's performance was her delivery when speaking. She speaks her lines in a monotone which adds to the chilling aspect rather than detracts from it. Now, I admit, at first it seemed kind of odd taking that track, but as her scenes went on I gradually came to see how effective that decision to do the part that way was. And it effectively fit in with the makeup that she had in the part.

 

Christmas Past ghost

 

Just as impressive was The Ghost of Christmas Present (Tramell Tillman). I still think that Edward Woodward's portrayal was the closest to the actual character Dickens wrote, and Tramell's portrayal is quite a bit different from the one we traditionally expect. Tillman's Ghost is decidedly more gauche than any that have come before him, but he manages to not make the character a caricature. 

 

Christmas Present ghost

 

The Ghost of Christmas Future is no different from the many that have come before him. He is still the gaunt, hooded, bony hand figure that you have come to expect (Dorian Harewood's portrayal in An American Christmas Carol being the only departure that I can remember...)

 

Christmas Future ghost

 

I won't reveal the way the film altered the denouement of the final ending here. I will say that traditionalists might object. It doesn't drastically change, just gives the characters a different interaction. Does it matter? Ultimately, no, but if you are one who wants to see a particular ending to the story played out, it's not exactly the same.

The fact that director Ti West has a huge reputation for his horror output probably had some influence on the presence of some of the scenes were the other ghosts try to attack Scrooge. And here, they mostly come off as being there as a sort of attempt to add a more stark ghost movie, or sometimes even zombie movie cachet to the film. This is the reason why I recommend that you leave the smaller ones at home.   

Johnny Depp gets mixed reviews for his work. His portrayal of Scrooge is nowhere near Academy Award level, and, really, has anything he's ever done been Academy level? 

(Right now some of you are saying "But, Quiggy... he was nominated for an Oscar for Neverland, but I would say he was probably a distant fifth in the voting against Jamie Foxx, Clint Eastwood, Leonardo DiCaprio and Don Cheadle, and I personally would have him to have changed places with Paul Giamatti in Sideways. And I'm not alone there. I guess I should add his first appearance as Jack Sparrow which also got a nom, and that was pretty good, although, again, I would not have called it Oscar level). 

I thought he did a decent job, however. He manages to occupy the character without turning him into a caricature. He doesn't exactly chew up the scenery like you might expect from some of his previous roles. And, bonus, the makeup department did a damn good job on him. If you didn't know it was Depp going in in, I would hazard a guess that you probably wouldn't know it was actually him. 

 

 

 

It is rather hard to not compare him to previous incarnations of Scrooge. But that is more to blame on the script than Depp's portrayal. For myself, based on his reactions throughout the redemption sequences, I was wondering whether this Scrooge would end up not being redeemed after all.  At times when I was expecting a little bit of mellowing of the character's hard heart he still seems to be reluctant to let these revelations have any effect on him. 

  

So, how is it being received on the critical front? 

Well, The Catholic Spirit website says it's a "yuletide treat for all but the easily frightened" and that it "ranks as a fresh and ethically insightful iteration of an oft-told yarn". But it warns, as I said in my own review, that it's probably not one to take the kids to see. Focus on the Family's "Plugged In" blogger is of the opinion that there are much better movie versions out there. But those are from the more religious sector of the blogosphere.

Other reviews are pretty much mixed as well. As would be expected, a lot of them seem to question whether we really needed another interpretation of A Christmas Carol. (And my response to that would be why the hell not? But then I am prejudiced since the story is my favorite Christmas story...) 

Early ratings have given this movie a current Rotten Tomatoes rating of 53%. It's way too early to give any financial data on it, of course. I saw the first showing for my local theater and there were only four other people in the theater, but that is no real indication since this was 2 in the afternoon, not a prime time showing. 

It remains to be seen. obviously, how history will treat this movie. If I'm still around in another 5 years, maybe I'll come back to this movie and give it a second look in light of how time has altered it's reception. But at this point I am recommending it, especially if you are, like me, a devoted fan of the overall story.

Drive safely, folks.

Quiggy

 


  

Wednesday, November 11, 2026

Blowing in the Wind

 

 


 

This is my entry in the Cinema Couture: The Art Of Illusion Blogathon hosted by Classic Movie Blog Association. 


A few years ago, I had the opportunity to go see Gone With the Wind in a theater. The venue was The Ritz in Austin, Texas. The theater had been around since the 1920's, although it had at times been a different kind of venue. It spent some time being a place to go see live bands, as well as turns at being a valid movie theater. Currently it is a comedy club, but from 2007 to 2021 it served as a movie theater under the auspices of Alamo Drafthouse.

 

The neat thing about The Ritz was that it was a classic old theater, with the seating style basically unaltered from it's days during the heyday of it's existence. The Ritz had two screens (I think). The approach to the actual seating had a small lobby with stairs going up to enter the theater. The seating was probably altered just enough to make them more comfortable to modern audiences, but still laid out in much the same way as it had been during it's first opening. 

 


 

It was originally built in the 1920's and is noted as being the first movie theater built in Austin specifically to show the new "talkies"; movies that actually had sound as opposed to the older "silents". 

The experience of seeing it at the Ritz in 2021 was especially memorable. I'm not sure about ALL of the films that Alamo Drafthouse showed during the Flashback Cinema, but on the occasions when I went to see a film in the Flashback Cinema series (another one I saw was It's A Wonderful Life)  there was an employee who would come out and give a little historical background to the film showing that day. In this particular showing a young lady came out on the stage in front of the screen and gave a little history.

The really memorable part of this exhibition is that the young lady came out in an outfit inspired by the Carol Burnett Show parody of the film, in which Carol, as Starlett O'Hara, came out dressed in an outfit made from one of the mansion's curtains (complete with the curtain rod). Don't have a picture of the young lady in the theater that day, but here is the original Carol Burnett scene to give you an idea...

 


The background to this incident was that the girl said she had mentioned she was going to talk about Gone With the Wind and her father mentioned the classic TV parody. The girl had never seen, nor even heard of, the parody so her father sat her down and showed her the entire episode, and the girl decided to do something similar for her presentation.  

So earlier this year a notice popped up in my Facebook feed that Gone with the Wind was going to be making another appearance in the theater and, coincidentally enough, one of the dates it was going to be showing was on October 10th, which was my sister's birthday. Most years I have a problem with finding something for her birthday, usually settling for something mundane, like taking her to dinner. But, as you know if you have been reading this blog over the years, her tastes in movies tend towards the old classics. And by classics I mean dramas and westerns, but not horror or sci-fi or anything even remotely outre. Which means about 90% or more of the movies I review could safely be classed as "not her cup of tea". (She is definitely not watching White Zombie with me, much less A Clockwork Orange.) 

But this movie falls easily into a category of one she likes. So, last month we went to the local theater.

Note: Gone With the Wind is a classic in the annals of Hollywood. As such, I have no illusions that any of this stuff will be revelations that 95% or more of you didn't already know. I am deeply indebted to Cynthia Marylee Molt who, in 1990, published a volume Gone with the Wind on Film which provided much of the information I used for this piece. Also, many trivia notations came from a Turner Classics production, The Making of a Legend, a documentary made on the production of the film.

The background to the film has a fairly long and intriguing story. The novel on which it was based was started by the author, Margaret Mitchell, as a way to occupy her time while she recovered from an automobile accident. It took her something like 10 years, off and on, to complete, and when it was finally published it was an international best seller. 

The casting of the film is a legend in itself. Due to the popularity and renown of the novel, there was a great interest in the casting of the primary characters. Especially for the headlining role of Scarlett O'Hara. Virtually every actress in Hollywood of an appropriate age (and even some not so appropriate) saw themselves as the best choice to play the role. Even the public got into the debate. According to the  aforementioned documentary, a public poll of who would be the ideal Scarlett ranked the following as the best choice (in order): Bette Davis, Katharine Hepburn, Miriam Hopkins, Margaret Sullivan, Joan Crawford and Barbara Stanwyck. (As a side note, I think Hepburn or Davis would have been good choices, but I think Crawford would have been a bad choice, even though she would have added some nuances to the vindictive side of Scarlett...)

An incomplete list (but including some of the more notable applicants and considered possibilities) for the role would include Lucille Ball, Tallulah Bankhead, Claudette Colbert, Paulette Goddard, Jean Harlow, Susan Hayward, Carole Lombard, Lana Turner and even, (believe it or not), Margaret Mitchell herself!

The part of Rhett Butler was almost a shoo-in for Clark Gable. Nearly everyone thought he was the only possible actor to play the role. But I discovered, reading the reference work on the film cited above, that Mitchell's choice was... wait for it... Groucho Marx! Gary Cooper, Douglas Fairbanks, Errol Flynn, Basil Rathbone and Randolph Scott were considered.

Another interesting contender: The part of Belle, the brothel madam, could have been played by Mae West. As much as I would like to have seen her in that role, I have to admit that I feel the movie would have suffered some if she was in it, mainly because I think she would have drawn attention away from the central characters whenever she was on camera. The role was eventually awarded to Ona Munson, who did a good job.

The costume designer for Gone with the Wind was Walter Plunkett. Because of the Hays Code, many films suffered a little because of the strictures of propriety that the Code enforced. Molt notes in her book that producers clashed with those rules in some productions because you couldn't really be historically accurate in costumes, mainly because the real historical style of clothing was a bit too risque for the times. For instance, the 1934 version of Cleopatra: "for which authentic clothing would have been no clothing at all" and "Forever Amber (1947) {would have required} the bawdy deshabillé of a woman during the Court of Charles II in England". 

For Gone with the Wind, Plunkett had no strictures, since the fashion of the South circa the late 1800's was pretty much along the same lines as what the Code established was allowable. Even the scene where the young women are preparing for nap time, garbed in night clothes, was reasonably sensible for the Code. And the dresses worn by the female characters in public are astounding. 

Sets for the film are also pretty impressive. The only one that really suffers, in my opinion, is the scene involving the burning of Atlanta. Although it is rather impressive in look, the sets, which were really older sets for very obviously NOT southern US settings, is just a little off. Many of the buildings burning look exactly like what they really were: settings from the 1933 film King Kong and also from The Garden of Allah. 


 

As well, since this scene was the first one filmed, prior to the prime casting, stunt doubles were used in most of the scene. Not all that obvious when watching on a small screen, but watching it on a movie theater, many of the long shots emphasized, unintentionally, that that was not Gable and Leigh in the carriage. The rest of the film did have some great settings. I was particularly impressed by the dishevelled look of Tara, post Civil War, when Scarlett returned home. 

 

I will say, at this point, that if you have never had the privilege of seeing the film on the big screen you should jump at the opportunity if it comes your way.  Hopefully you won't have to wait until the (probable) 100th anniversary re-release in 2039...

 

 

Gone With the Wind (1939): 

Note: Given that it's sure bet that you already know the entire plot by heart (and if you don't what have you been waiting for to watch this?), most of what follows will be a musing on my impressions of how the film played out and the characters involved, rather than an in-depth discussion of the story itself. 

The film opens with Max Steiner's score as we see a party being held at Tara. Scarlett O'Hara (Vivien Leigh) is surrounded by admirers, hoping to gain her attention. Among these are the two Tarleton brothers, Stuart and Brent (note: the credits are in error as George Reeves is credited as Brent, but actually played Stuart and Fred Crane is credited as Stuart, but actually played Brent. Apparently the credits were already made and it was deemed too costly to redo them. But, unless you were familiar with one or the other, or both, it wouldn't stand out too much, since both characters are pretty much the same...)


 

 


 

Scarlett toys with the affections all of her potential suitors, but her true love is reserved for Ashley Wilkes (Leslie Howard). Unfortunately, the devotion is not requited by Ashley. Instead, he is betrothed to Melanie Hamilton (Olivia de Havilland). Which doesn't set well with Scarlett, obviously. Scarlett comes off in this film as a spoiled and manipulative brat, and her actions throughout gave me nervous shivers. I felt sorry for every man that crossed her path, and couldn't help but feel relief for Ashley, who escaped a lifetime of pure distress if he had been the unfortunate victim of her machinations.


 

Because Scarlett has a single-minded obsession with Ashley, she ultimately marries Melanie's brother, Charles (Rand Brooks), not because she truly loves him; she is only doing it to hopefully inspire a little jealousy in Ashley. (Manipulative bitch that she is). The marriage is doomed, however, when, after the start of the Civil War, Charles is killed in action. Scarlett doesn't spend much time grieving over the loss however.


 

Rhett Butler (Clark Gable) makes his appearance on the scene, and Scarlett takes a dislike to his brash manner, but does eventually mellow towards him, especially after he helps her and Melanie escape Atlanta during the burning of the city by the Union. 

 


She returns to Tara, where the financial troubles of keeping her beloved home cause her to, once again, use her wiles to get money to keep it afloat by marrying Frank Kennedy (Carroll Nye). (Once again, Scarlett's self, self-entitled personality grated on me). Frak also dies, and Scarlett has about as much grieving over the loss as she did for Charles.

 


Eventually Scarlett and Rhett hook up. Rhett, for his part, seems to love Scarlett and her independent spirit, but once again, Scarlett really only holds her true love for Ashley, even though he is still married and devoted to Melanie. The relationship between Scarlett and Rhett gradually deteriorates as he realizes that Scarlett is just as single-minded and immature as when he first met her. This comes to a head when their daughter, Bonnie, dies. Rhett truly was devoted to Bonnie, although it seemed to me that Scarlett just considered her a burden to be borne.


 

Even the ending didn't change my opinion of Scarlett, as her grief over the loss of Rhett's love came off more as a "woe is me, nobody loves me, everybody hates me" scene. Still selfish, even to the last. Her final words in the movie are "I'll think of some way to get him back! After all... tomorrow is another day!" Personally, my opinion of what Scarlett does from here on out is reflected by Rhett's final words: "Frankly, my dear, I don't give a damn!"


 

So, even though I truly don't like Scarlett, I think the movie is astounding, especially in tems of the way it was filmed, the sets, the costumes and the music. Given a much more likable main female character, this could easily be one of my top ten movies. It still ranks in the top 25, which is a credit to those other factors. And it is worth watching multiple times.

One final note: some critics have disparaged the film for it's portrayal of the slaves as being happy in their position. Were some slaves comfortable with their position as this movie implies? Maybe, but probably not.  That doesn't detract from the film for me. I especially liked the Mammy (Hattie McDaniel) character, despite the fact that her devotion to the O'Hara family may have been unrealistic. Assuredly this is a film that deserves a better reputation than the likes of, say, Birth of a Nation in it's depiction of the Negro. Whether or not you agree, there were some serious changes made during the filming process. Equality, whether agreeably or grudgingly, was upheld at may points. For instance, one article I read stated that the restrooms had to be desegregated on set if the Negro cast were going to continue. And Clark Gable said that unless equality were a part of the set he would not appear in the film. These may seem like minor concessions to the 21st century mind, but given the climate of the time, there were fairly progressive.

With a budget of only about $4 million, the film was an astounding success at the box office, bringing in $380 million in ticket sales (to put that in perspective, a ticket for a film in 1939 was only about 25 cents). The film virtually swept the Oscars that year. Out of 13 nominations it took home 8 of those, including a record setting first Oscar to a black actress, Hattie McDaniel for Best Supporting Actress. Of the five that the movie did NOT win, the most egregious loss, in my opinion, was giving Best Actor to Robert Donat (Goodbye, Mr. Chips) over Clark Gable. 

The film ranks #4 on the 100 Years...100 Movies list put out by the American Film Institute, behind Citizen Kane, Casablanca and The Godfather. (It's no secret about how much I don't like Citizen Kane, but I think the other two deserve their spots, so I personally would not object if it were ranked #3... even if it wouldn't garner that high a spot in my own personal list.) 

This viewing, as I said earlier, was a birthday present for my sister. We had a good time, and it's always a nice thing to see a movie that was previously only available on whatever small screen format that could be found. A side note: My own birthday is coming up next month, and I am hoping we can do another outing, because The Maltese Falcon is being re-released. 

That's it for this time. Drive safely, folks.

Quiggy